Let's be clear from the start: this isn't a novel. There's no plot twist on page 200. But the 'story' Hostetler tells is just as compelling. 'Handbook to the Mennonite Hymnary' is the ultimate companion guide to a specific hymnbook. He takes each hymn, one by one, and unpacks its origins. You'll learn about the poets who wrote the words, often during times of personal struggle or great faith. You'll discover the composers behind the melodies, some of which are centuries old and traveled across oceans. Hostetler provides historical context, explains theological references, and even points out interesting musical details. The journey is from the printed page of the hymnary back through time to the moments and people that created these enduring songs.

Why You Should Read It

You should read this if you've ever felt a hymn move you. This book adds layers of meaning to that experience. Suddenly, that song you've sung a hundred times isn't just lyrics and notes; it's a link to a 16th-century Anabaptist facing persecution, or a 19th-century revivalist's heartfelt prayer. Hostetler's writing, while scholarly, has a quiet reverence. He's not just cataloging facts; he's showing you why this music is a living, breathing part of a faith tradition. It turns passive singing into an active connection with history. For anyone in the Mennonite tradition, it's a priceless resource that deepens worship. For outsiders, it's a fascinating look at how a community defines itself through its music.

Final Verdict

This is a niche book, but a brilliant one for the right reader. It's perfect for Mennonites and Amish who want to understand their musical heritage on a deeper level. It's also great for musicians, choir directors, or historians of religion who are curious about hymnology. If you're a general reader looking for a fast-paced story, this isn't it. But if you're the kind of person who loves knowing the 'story behind the story,' who finds beauty in tradition and meaning in details, you'll find Hostetler's handbook surprisingly absorbing. Think of it less as a book you read cover-to-cover, and more as a reference you'll return to again and again, each time finding a new piece of the puzzle in a familiar song.